Our Testimonials

Penny went above and beyond to find the perfect home for my family at an affordable price. She was always there when i had a question. She negotiated with the sellers to have all repairs and she even got them to pay closing cost. I highly recommend her! My total out of pocket cost to get into my home was $400. Cant believe how fast the process was, less then a month to close. If you are unsure about buying a home contact Penny she is Super!

-T. Eells

I ran across Penny sitting at an open house last summer. I had just relocated here from VA and thought I would have to rent for at least a year before finding the perfect house to buy. So I was basically daydreaming at this open house, however am thankful we stopped in! Began working with Penny right away as I was on a short timeline to get out of our temporary rental. She was always available and always showed us homes in our preferred area. Homes were selling in a day or less for cash, so it was frustrating at times. But Penny was very fast with all contacts, offers, and all that other not so fun stuff that arises when looking for a home. I would HIGHLY recommend her to anyone. I have already referred some friends who she found a home for as well.

-K. DiBartolo

Penny Seahorn was by far the best real estate agent that we have ever used, with no exaggeration. She went above and beyond to make the process as smooth and seamless as possible. She even took a large amount of paint to a hazardous materials facility, in her own car. As the home was two hours from where we are currently living, it was great to have her expertise available to us. I highly recommend Penny and feel very confident that you will be pleased with her service if you decide to hire her. She is the best!


I highly recommend Penny as a realtor. She is very knowledgeable not only only about the area, but specific things to look for when looking at houses. She has been a great help from start to finish on our journey to becoming home owners.

-R. Mast

Penny was the best! Always answered our questions, especially being first time home buyers. Very knowledgeable and trust worthy! All I have to say is thank you and if at decided to sell and buy again years on down the road you will be our first person to contact!

-C. Canez

We had the very fortunate experience to have Andrea Ortega sell our home. From the initial listing right through closing, Andrea ensured that the entire process went smoothly. She responded immediately to all of our questions, and was dedicated to making sure we had all of the information that was needed. We would recommend Andrea without hesitation---she's the best!

-M. Daku

Andrea Ortega is a "ROCK STAR!". She was involved from the beginning to the end and was an amazing advocate and representative for me during the entire process. She is approachable, dependable, and very professional. I would recommend her to anyone who is looking for a dependable Realtor.

-S. Smith

Andrea Ortega was just amazing! She always responded in a timely manner, kept it professional and was efficient. We enjoyed having her as our realtor. Would definitely recommend to anyone!

-H. Munoz

Cheryl exceeded my expectations. I have worked with several realtors in the past and none can compare to the dedication and skills that Cheryl provides. She was patient and accommodating during the process, which was a challenge, as I submitted three different contracts on properties prior to final purchase. Cheryl's commitment and personalized service made the process a positive experience. I will definitely recommend Cheryl to family and friends for any real estate needs.

-T. Friday

After interviewing several agents for the sale of our property in Mesa we decided to list with Cheryl. During her presentation she was by far the most prepared and had a well thought out marketing plan and understood the local market. The listing process was simple and as we lived out of state she kept us informed as was able to execute documents remotely.

Had an offer very close to our list in less that a week and closed quickly, once again remotely.

I would recommend Cheryl to anyone selling in the area.

-B. Braun

Finding someone that you feel you can trust to have your best interest at heart is a really lucky break when you are selling and buying real estate in a market that you don't live in. Matt has understood my situation and never appeared judgmental or condescending. I would recommend him to anyone shopping for a real estate agent.

-J. Maurer

Matt was extremely professional. We had a contract on one townhouse when the original condo do you want to came back on the market. Mandi jumped on it and switch the contracts and we got the house we wanted within a week we closed on it. He only showed me what we was looking for.

I will and have passed out his cards to people I know looking.

-J. Prague

We would not hesitate to use Matt again, or to recommend him to friends and family. He is very knowledgeable, accommodating and professional. Matt really went above and beyond during the sale of our home and purchase of a new home. He gave us valuable advice and guided us through the selling and buying process. Let's face it, buying/selling a home can be a stressful and emotional time, but Matt was the calming voice we needed.

-S. Spisak

In looking for a home, it was nice to have someone knowledgable in guiding me in that process. Matt Pennington never dropped the ball and was on top of the paperwork, escrow, communications, and inspections. He never ignored my calls or emails and always returned a reply within a few hours. Even after the closing, Matt followed up to make sure everything was ok.

I will definitely use Matt Pennington in all my future real estate transactions.


Michael Tarver really is the best agent. He went above and beyond for us to make sure we got into a home that we love. This is a tough buyers market and mike's dedication to his job and his clients really made the difference. He works day and night to make sure we could see homes immediately and then once we found "the one" mike worked tirelessly to make sure we got everything we needed to be happy. He has excellent negotiating skills and helped us through all hurdles. We wont ever use anyone else after our experience with him.

-B. Gearhart

Ask Your Agent a Question

Ask Our Lending Partner a Question

Download Our Mobile App

Download Millions Mapped

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

American AllStar Realty
6642 E Baseline Rd Ste 101
Mesa, AZ