Our Testimonials

As a first time home buyer, this tedious home buying process went extremely smooth. My wife and I couldn't be happier with our beautiful new home. We owe all thanks to our wonderful realtor Penny Seahorn. She was with us every step of the way. She always maintained great communication, was flexible, transparent, very kind, thoughtful, and professional. A year later and we still have a relationship with Penny. If and when we are ready to upgrade, we will be sure to call Penny. We strongly advise you to do the same. Shes great. Thank you so much Penny.

-J. Evensiosky

Kelley Kemmis helped my significant other and I purchase our new build house and she was amazing! She consistently went out of her way to provide us unparalleled service, going above and beyond. She consistently made herself available to us for any questions/concerns we had, as well as came with us for every walkthrough we had to give her input when asked. Highly, highly recommend to anyone considering a home purchase.

-S. Hamilton

We met Penny at an open house, we immediately felt comfortable talking with about what we were looking for. Penny worked tirelessly to find us that "just perfect" home. She was very professional and also very friendly, we have stayed in touch since then (2016). Thank you Penny!

-E. Thompson

Kelley kemmis for the win. Getting a realtor who is patient, knowledgeable, and able to give you a flawless and amazing experience from the start is a rare thing.. BUT.. enter, Kelley kemmis. She is all of that and more. Multiple successful closings for numerous of my close friends is enough proof that her competence in the industry is unsurpassable.
She is a 5 star realtor, and will give any client what they deserve and get you in to the home you've always dreamed of.

-B. Krieger

Working with Penny Seahorn to sell my home this past winter was a dream! She was knowledgeable, kind, patient, and thorough. Penny went above and beyond to make sure I understood every step of the process. Her ability to highlight the beauty in a vintage home was impressive. She even looked out for the safety of my pets during showings! I have been recommending Penny to all of my friends considering a home move!

-A. McIntosh

I started my search online and luckily I ran across Matt Pennington with American Allstar Realty. He was by far the best realtor I have ever worked with! His knowledge of the market and attention to detail were amazing, but what was special to us was that he truly cared about our family and what we wanted for our forever home. I HIGHLY recommend Matt Pennington if you are looking to buy or sell a home.

-C. Hansen

Two years ago, I sent a random email hoping it would get to someone that could help me. I was interested in my first home, and wasn’t sure where to start. I received a text 20 minutes later from Kelley! I was always told that buying a house was very stressful, but you’d never guess that with Kelley by your side. She made everything so effortless, and made it one of the best experiences I’ve had. We absolutely love our home and the hard work that Kelley put in for us, day in and day out. She is a great person, and truly looks out for her clients. We have and will continue to recommend her to all of our friends and family! Thanks again Kelley!

-M. Burough

Penny Seahorn is a fantastic agent! She spent multiple weekends showing me houses and helping me through the home buying process as a first time home buyer!

-E. Griffin

Michael Tarver with American AllStar Realty is a true Professional when it comes to buying and selling homes. He is dedicated to ensuring the highest levels of satisfaction for his clients. Michael has assisted my wife and I with our first home purchase as well as assisted colleagues of mine in their Real Estate endeavors. Michael was always available and worked tirelessly through many negotiations and contracts until we found the perfect home for our needs. I will continue to recommend and work with Michael and his team, I wish them all the best!

-J. Fullerton

Andrea was very patient and dedicated to helping me find the perfect home for myself . She was always there when I needed her and helped me through every step in the process. I strongly recommend her for anyone looking to buy or sell a house!

-B. Bulloch

Kelley Kemmis helped us through the process of selling and buying a new home. She worked tirelessly to find our perfect house and was patient and supportive during the buying and inspection process. Anytime we get lost she was there as a supportive voice. American Allstar Realty knows how to hire amazing people.

-N. Baldwin

Michael was wonderful. He was very patient with me. He helped me sell my Townhouse and purchase my new place. He helped me get more than I expected for my townhouse. I would recommend Michael to anyone that asks.

-J. Barber

Andrea Ortega has helped my family 3 times with finding a home. She was ready any time we needed. And was very informative and helpful.. we will use her again if and when its necessary

-M. Graston

Andrea is an awesome realtor! She was always willing to show us homes, no matter when, including evenings and weekends. Always great service with any questions. Highly recommend!

-M. Oliver

Kelley helped me find a nice home for my mom and I. We love our new home and recommend American AllStar Realty for your home buying and selling. Great people, always nice, friendly, helpful.

-J. Eich

Ask Your Agent a Question

Ask Our Lending Partner a Question

Download Our Mobile App

Download Millions Mapped
Reviews on Zillow
Average Rating
"We recently had the pleasure of using Kelley Kemmis as our realtor in the sale of our Mom's home. Kelley listened to our concerns, was very thorough with everything, proactive and always a step ahead ... more "
5/5.0
by cdblanchard1
"Kelley Kemmis is an excellent realtor, very helpful and knowledgeable too.
She was able to identify our needs and desire for a certain property criteria and guide us through the process to choose ... more "
5/5.0
by hazmshab
"Kelley Kemmis was a pleasure to work with. She was always available to answer all questions and help me and wife through the process. She made the whole buying process very simple and handled all the ... more "
5/5.0
by user581673

Property Search









Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

American AllStar Realty
6642 E Baseline Rd Ste 101
Mesa, AZ
602-353-7375