Matt Pennington

Matt Pennington Headshot

Matt has been a licensed Real Estate Broker since 2003 and with American AllStar Realty since 2005. Matt lives and loves real estate, especially assisting Buyers and Sellers in residential transactions.

I have always held a vision of personal real estate service that would far exceed customer expectations. Myself and my team of agents are able to negotiate competently on a clients' behalf and consistently handle even the most complex property transactions with ease. This teamwork, attention to detail and serving the customer with an above-and-beyond philosophy, has helped American AllStar Realty succeed in spite of a sometimes-adverse economy. A solid reputation has been built through hard work, integrity and a strong code of ethics.

I am a hardworking professional, focused on delivering real results. You truly want someone in your corner when it comes to any real estate transaction.

Send Matt a Message

Finding someone that you feel you can trust to have your best interest at heart is a really lucky break when you are selling and buying real estate in a market that you don't live in. Matt has understood my situation and never appeared judgmental or condescending. I would recommend him to anyone shopping for a real estate agent.

-J. Maurer

Matt was extremely professional. We had a contract on one townhouse when the original condo do you want to came back on the market. Mandi jumped on it and switch the contracts and we got the house we wanted within a week we closed on it. He only showed me what we was looking for. I will and have passed out his cards to people I know looking.

-J. Prague

We would not hesitate to use Matt again, or to recommend him to friends and family. He is very knowledgeable, accommodating and professional. Matt really went above and beyond during the sale of our home and purchase of a new home. He gave us valuable advice and guided us through the selling and buying process. Let's face it, buying/selling a home can be a stressful and emotional time, but Matt was the calming voice we needed.

-S. Spisak

In looking for a home, it was nice to have someone knowledgable in guiding me in that process. Matt Pennington never dropped the ball and was on top of the paperwork, escrow, communications, and inspections. He never ignored my calls or emails and always returned a reply within a few hours. Even after the closing, Matt followed up to make sure everything was ok. I will definitely use Matt Pennington in all my future real estate transactions.


WOW, what can I say!! Matt was just Fantastic!! My Wife and I were just looking around at houses and just happened to meet Matt at a house we wanted to look at. We were so impressed with how he showed us around and explained things to us that we ended up using Matt as our Realtor!! It was such a easy transaction. We used the Finance Company Matt recommended and it was a breeze to buy the house!! Couldn't be Happier!!

-K. McDaniel

Matt Pennington made purchasing our home a very easy and stress free experience. I recommend him to anyone. If you looking for a honest, dependable, hard working realtor look no further, Matt is your guy!

-F. Ortiz

Matt was very considerate, knowledgeable and patient. I am very picky client. He was okay with that. As a team we worked to get me the perfect house for my first purchase. I will do all my business with him. He also has great connects and resources. As a banker I will refer all my clients who are in the market to purchase there new home.

-S. Knighten

I cannot think of anything but very positive things to say about the personal assistance Matt provides to customers. He is never pushy, always professional and polite, sometimes even funny. (ha ha) We had a stressful situation and we were not sure if it would be resolved. Matt knew just how to walk the line and gave us the best advise and comfort. He held the transaction together and was honestly concerned for both parties which we appreciated. I would highly recommend him to anyone interested in selling or purchasing a home. You will not be disappointed.

-J. Martin

Matt is AMAZING!!! I can honestly say we would not have gotten our dream house without him! He worked with us to find exactly what we wanted and didn't show us anything less than the best! He is a great negotiator and is fun to work with!

-J. Farnworth

As a first time home buyer I wasn't sure what to expect, Matt was very thorough, knowledgeable, and help put my mind at ease. Matt was always available when a house came on the market I wanted to see and I felt no pressure to buy or settle. I highly recommend Matt Pennington!

-E. Gomez

Matt Pennington was the best real estate agent I've ever dealt with he was attentive to my Needs & Wants was only giving me listings of stuff I wanted to see was able to meet as quickly as I was able to meet him to look at properties and to put the beds in on them when I found the property I wanted to put the offer in right away winter winter clothes on the house by the time we got to the appraisal there was a few hiccups where paint had to be scraped and peeled off of the house Matt Pennington not once but twice and help paint and scrape paint off this house so that it would pass inspection for the appraisal as far as I'm concerned he's the only real estate agent you should use

-D. Hidalgo

Matt is one of those guys I just trust. Period. He aided me 5 years ago when I bought my first house as a single bachelor, which is why I asked for him again when my now wife and I chose to relocate and buy another house. His communication is prompt, courteous and he is a wealth of knowledge. He makes the process easy and manageable and I think any of us can agree that is of value. Moreover, he treats you like family, aiding in final preparations, staging and locating the right resources for anything you may need. If you want a real estate agent in a fast car out to make a quick commission and not care about your personal interests, go elsewhere. If you want a trustworthy, reliable agent who has your best interests in mind, Talk to Mr. Pennington. He is, and will always be, our agent for life.

-J. Jameson

Matt was instrumental in guiding me through the sale of my home. This being my first home sale, it was refreshing and rewarding to have someone with so much experience help me through this process.

-E. Dagnino

Having Matt as your agent means that the work gets done quickly and, from the perspective of the customer, very smoothly. If there were snags or hurdles, I didn't know about them because Matt's swift and expert skills accomplished everything we hoped for even faster than the time frame we initially expected.

-N. Melton

As a first time home buyer, I was relieved to have a such a patient and knowledgeable real estate agent on my side. Matt took the time to find out exactly what we were looking for and only recommended the houses that fit our needs. He also gave us plenty of expert advice on a variety of topics along the way. I would recommend him to anyone looking for a new home.

-A. Christoffel

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

American AllStar Realty
6642 E Baseline Rd Ste 101
Mesa, AZ